jump to navigation

Independent Senator (quietly) (re)joins Labour Party. Not that she really left. September 28, 2009

Posted by WorldbyStorm in Irish Politics, The Left.

It may have slipped peoples notice, but the strangest thing happened last week when Senator Ivana Bacik, formerly Independent Senator, moved onto the Labour benches. Granted her candidacy for the Labour Party in the Dublin Central by-election, and her previous membership (and perhaps continuing, I’m not entirely certain of her status in that regard during the past two years since her election as an Independent) were great big clues that the life of the solitary Independent weren’t necessarily a permanent course she had fixed upon. But… one wonders what her plans are next. Can’t see a grateful Trinity electorate necessarily giving her the same support now she’s flying a party flag – they seem uncomfortable about such things. That is if there is even a TCD electorate if the government lasts and certain proposals come into play as regards the future of the Seanad. And that puzzles me a little. I’ve always had enormous admiration for her and she has taken an extremely courageous stance on a raft of issues over the years, and I quite respected her not quite in Labour approach over the past two years or so (which also, perhaps gave her more freedom than one might have expected) and it’s hard to see how this benefits her.

The comments in the illustrious second chamber on this topic were… well, read for yourselves…

Senator Joe O’Toole:In the meantime, I would like us to have a discussion on the public sector and what it is contributing to the economy in order that those working within it would see there is respect for them in some parts of public life.
During the summer the Leader of the House issued a statement on Seanad reform. Is he ready for it? We know about the University Senators and will go along with it. What about the next reform? There has been no word about it. The media hopped onto it and it is the one issue on which everyone is agreed. A House in respect of which every citizen of the State does not have a vote in its construction is no longer acceptable in a democracy. The McCarthy report is correct. The Seanad either needs to be reformed or abolished. That is the end of the matter.
I would like the House to note, with some sadness on these benches, that we have lost one of our illustrious Members who has moved slightly forward and to the right.
An Cathaoirleach:The Senator on the Order of Business please.
Senator Joe O’Toole:Senator Bacik has moved to the Labour Party benches.
Senator Cecilia Keaveney:Just as well she ran. [huh?]
Senator Alex White:In so far as Senator O’Toole is allowed to express his sadness at the loss of Senator Bacik to the Labour Party benches, I note with great pleasure that she has joined us on them. I am sure she will impress and prosper as much as she did on the other benches which, I notice, have been augmented by another Senator. We were not informed about that before the House met.
Senator Joe O’Toole:Of course, we were informed.
Senator Alex White:I wish the Sinn Féin and Independent Senators well in the forthcoming session.


Senator Ivana Bacik:I thank Senators Alex White and O’Toole for their kind words. Although I have made a small physical move forward and to the right, of course, I stay politically exactly where I was before, which is firmly on the left. I have the privilege of having been elected by the graduates of Dublin University to represent them in the Seanad and I will continue to work hard to do so.


Senator Rónán Mullen:That individual indicated that there is a certain irony in the EU providing the freedom to work and live in its different member states, yet Ireland will not grant the means to vote for those of us who may be out of the country on polling day. Can we have a debate on the need to change that position soon?
On a final point, I compliment and wish well my colleague, Senator Bacik. In moving to the Labour Party she has clearly wrestled with her conscience.
An Cathaoirleach:That is not relevant to the Order of Business.
Senator Rónán Mullen:I am not sure if she has won or lost that wrestling match.
An Cathaoirleach:The leaders of the groups have spoken on that matter.
Senator Rónán Mullen:Neither Senator O’Toole nor myself——
An Cathaoirleach:The Senator is not the leader of his group.
Senator Rónán Mullen:——is sure whether there will be a by-election on the Trinity panel but we would like to wish her well in any case. I can assure her that physically at least I will be behind her all the way from now on.
An Cathaoirleach:Senator Mullen, please desist. I call Senator Walsh.
Senator Cecilia Keaveney:Senator Bacik should watch her back. [huh- again?]
Senator Ivana Bacik:I will.


1. splinteredsunrise - September 28, 2009

Senator Keaveney has no business being sarky about changes of party flag. Bearing in mind her background with Provisional FF in Donegal…


2. Tim - September 28, 2009

“Although I have made a small physical move forward and to the right, of course, I stay politically exactly where I was before, which is firmly on the left.”

it’s like something out of The New Statesman…..


3. WorldbyStorm - September 28, 2009

I’d completely forgotten that splintered sunrise… hmmm…

Tim, there is that.


4. splinteredsunrise - September 28, 2009

Oh yeah, and the TCD electorate. Are they still keeping the electoral rolls up to date by checking the death notices in the IT? Really, whoever designed the Seanad must have been a disciple of surrealism. Not the most inspiring bit of the constitutional setup.


Tim - September 29, 2009

Have they been letting dead Trinnertarians vote?? Or do I just not get the reference ..?
The Senate is not exactly “democratic”, but it is interesting…


5. WorldbyStorm - September 29, 2009

I think it’s improved since then 🙂

But idiosyncratic is the word.


6. non voting alum - September 29, 2009

I’m suspicious about why Bacik ran as an independent for the Senate seat to begin with. Whatever she may be it is not independent. She is labour to the core.


7. EWI - September 29, 2009

I can assure her that physically at least I will be behind her all the way from now on.

I’m not sure what to make of that, coming as it does from the curiously bachelor Senator in question…


8. Neil - October 1, 2009

Just to clarify – Ivana was always a Labour Party member (and indeed chair of one of our branches until recently). This is the first time she has joined the PLP, so she has joined, and not rejoined.

She gives her own reasons on the homepage of her website: http://www.ivanabacik.com/


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: