jump to navigation

The government under threat? If only. February 5, 2013

Posted by WorldbyStorm in Economy, Irish Politics.

Reading between the lines of the media at the weekend one would think that the Coalition was under enormous, perhaps terminal, internal and external pressure. The SBP suggests that Labour is on the brink of rejection of the abortion plans brought to Cabinet because they’re ‘too restrictive’. Their particular problem is with the panel of doctors who will be charged with assessing cases. There is certainly a point there that this seems, on the face of it – and putting aside the broader issue of just how wrong headed an approach this is in for many of us – to be problematic in the extreme.

Fine Gael, as articulated by James Reilly, want up to five doctors.

The LP proposal is hardly any better, wanting ‘only’ three, two psychiatrists and a GP.

And then there’s other pressure from outside. Gilmore apparently ‘warned’ Merkel that without a deal on the bank debt the ‘coalition could fall’. Pat Leahy suggests that:

Gilmore told Merkel, European Commission president Jose Manuel Barroso, European Council chief Herman van Rompuy, French prime minister Jean-Marc Ayrault and Finnish prime minister Jyrki Katainen that failure to secure a deal on the promissory notes would have the “most profound consequences” for the two-year old coalition.

Some of us might be forgiven for taking that with a pinch of salt. Precisely what mechanism would initiate any such fall? Both Fine Gael and Labour retain jointly a commanding majority, a super-majority. There is little or no incentive for them to leave government, even in the wake of a rebuff from Europe on the debt. Indeed for them to do so would be unprecedented – not least because they’ve toughed it out so far – and in contradiction to their respective election platforms – with nary a whisper of resignation on their lips.

If they go it will be, almost certainly, under their own steam. Granted we’re told that:

Tensions have also been growing between Fine Gael and Labour on the issue, with Labour ministers much more concerned than Fine Gael about the consequences of not securing a deal.

But if so – and again, this is putting aside the issue as to the real significance of any deal over promissory notes – it seems unlikely on past experience that such tensions will lead to any substantive breach.
Which makes all this seem a little cosmetic. And if it seems cosmetic from this side of the Irish Sea, then one presumes that it seems doubly so to Merkel et al.

And meanwhile Michael Noonan’s view last night?

Speaking in Limerick today Mr Noonan said payment is not due until March 31st which is almost two months away adding “I don’t understand why people are getting so excited at present”.

“I don’t put the two issues together at all I don’t see any threat to the coalition government,” he said.


1. callumldoherty - February 5, 2013

I agree with the sentiments of no, real, immediate threat. Over this particular issue, in any case. The coalition, while perhaps unpopular, will see no demise before the next election at the earliest in my opinion.
Stories such as the one posted may be a double-edged sword for Labour, however, as the media exposure of such events will only provoke a demand for answers and solutions, something Miliband et al may forego is they indeed consider the issue(s) to be cosmetic…in the eyes of the public, anyway.

A good article, though.


ejh - February 5, 2013

Stories such as the one posted may be a double-edged sword for Labour, however, as the media exposure of such events will only provoke a demand for answers and solutions, something Miliband et al may forego



2. greengoddess2 - February 5, 2013

There will be a breach if Gilmore plans an exit. Will he? This is what you should be debating. Meanwhile listening to Hollande in EP and hoping he will help us. Even if our own people won’t 😡


3. shea - February 5, 2013

yeah gilmore was asked some question via the promissory note and the stability of the government on RTE news last night. seemed odd with his off the cuff scripted answer.. noonan on the other had looked like he was starring down the barrel of a gun. i don’t think he was asked any question on the stability of the government.


4. Ghandi - February 5, 2013

An odd article in the Herald (not that I’d put any store by that rag) tonight that Costello ( the family’s done all right out of this government thank you very much) is going to start re picketing the Mater Hospital every saturday again just like before the election because of the delay in the new A&E. A minister protesting about his own government policies. Maybe they are gearing up for something, save your own skin at all costs.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: