jump to navigation

Another sign of the times…Local Government in the UK December 18, 2014

Posted by WorldbyStorm in Economy, The Left.

Aditya Chakrabortty writes in the Guardian about the provision of services by Tory controlled Barnet Council in the UK. Read it and see the next wave of ‘service’ changes…

Between January 2012 and October 2013, Barnet farmed out its care for people with disabilities, legal services, cemeteries and crematoriums, IT, finance, HR, planning and regeneration, trading standards and licensing, management of council housing, environmental health, procurement, parking, and the highways department.
This evening, a full council meeting will vote on whether to consider cuts and “alternative delivery models” for another tranche of services, including libraries, rubbish collection, street gritters and children’s speech therapy, among others. Should they go the way of the rest and be outsourced, the local Unison branch calculates that Barnet council will shrink from having 3,200 staff in September 2012 to just 332.

And Chakrabortty notes one crucial element of this, away and beyond the ‘service provision’, such as is left:

And a tour of the neighbourhood teaches you that when cuts reach a certain magnitude, it’s not just services you lose; it’s an entire democratic institution. Residents can show you lots of missing services: the borough is right now consulting on plans to squeeze the vast majority of libraries to around 540 sq ft, or the size of a Hampstead Garden Suburb living room.


For those who live and work in Barnet, their local affairs are now handled remotely by people hundreds of miles away, who know nothing about them or the area. Payroll for what remains of council staff is done in Belfast, while for schools it’s Carlisle. Pension queries go to Darlington. Benefits end up in Blackburn. Parking notices come from Croydon. Calls to the local library are first directed to Coventry. Even births, deaths and marriages are managed in Brent.
Got a complaint? Then you have speak to someone you’ll never see – that is, if you can speak to them at all. Capita has admitted previously “capping” phone calls: throwing callers off the line when things get too busy. So rather than rely on their local institutions, residents increasingly depend on their councillors to intercede.


This is what happens when you lose locally accountable public servants. It’s also the cost of losing local expertise. Take the legal department, now run out of Harrow. The result was that in early summer, Barnet councillors were given the wrong reports to vote on. The resulting mockery led to the commissioning of an independent report that stated on its first page: “There is no one who understands local government law in depth at Barnet. Barnet employs no lawyers.”

And as Chakrabortty notes, the deals Barnet has struck with Capita are such that they’re are locked in for ten years, at least. There’s no democratic oversight, no democratic control, no democracy, no there, no local. And this isn’t about saving money – as he notes the Tories were pushing this line long before the current financial crisis. This is about shaving away the state – actually slicing away the state.

A very good point made in comments is that this isn’t just about now, or the next ten years, but that by the very nature of this process it removes institutional knowledge from councils and other state entities as regards the provision of services, thereby increasing the challenge for reinstating services under democratic local control.

This has happened in this state over the past decade (and by the way, there’s nothing more nauseating than hearing the LP bleat about how bin protests ‘led’ to privatisation – they could have put taking those services back into the public sector into their election manifesto if that was the case, strangely they didn’t). It is a process that continues, that is where services aren’t actually cut outright.


1. CL - December 18, 2014

Welcome to neoliberal dystopia.


6/5against - December 18, 2014

…and if the next government here is FF/FG, this will be rolled out in a huge way. And there will be little chance of undoing the damage for a generation or more.


2. CMK - December 18, 2014

Capita are encroaching bit-by-bit but steadily into aspects of the Irish public sector. As, I’m sure, are other services companies. When the Fiscal Treaty really puts the squeeze on public spending here, which will be even worse now that the government are committed to tax cuts for top earners, these companies will aggressively pitch for business.

Spot on about the Labour Party – precisely no-one will mourn its passing.

Chakrabortty is an astute observer of actually existing neo-liberalism and as surely as night follows day, what is rolled out in the UK will arrive here soon enough.

Speaking of the extinction of local services by local councils, the EU seem to have some pretty big social policy initiatives for the new Commission. For instance, an attack, through European legislation, on paid maternity leave.


Meanwhile, a civics lesson from the Irish Times: the last paragraph of the article reads:

‘For those pinning their hopes on a new dawn driven by the radical left, the uncomfortable truth is that the world of bondholders and high finance matters. It’s a message that centrist government parties across Europe, will be hoping to convey as they battle with the emergent power of the radical left.’



CL - December 18, 2014

That’s about the fourth article in the I.T. in the past few days making the same conservative argument. Better to go to a more progressive source, the Telegraph, to get a more balanced view, as Pasionario linked here.


3. 6to5against - December 18, 2014

What’s interesting about the bond markets is that they seem to be broadly apolitical. They have leant to gov’ts right and left the world over. I suspect that they’re really only interested in getting their money back. As such they might be anxious about unstable regimes, or those that are wildly wasteful, but I doubt they’re very interested in wealth distribution and taxation levels.


CMK - December 18, 2014

I read somewhere recently, but can’t remember where, that the ‘bond markets’ are most blokes in their mid to late twenties on the trading floors of major financial capitalist institutions. They all share a basic outlook on the world (no prizes for guessing roughly what that would be) and the look at the data, and interpret it, through the frame of that outlook. In short, they are not really that apolitical. But, as I say, I can’t find where I read it.


4. irishelectionliterature - December 19, 2014

http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/cameron-slashes-manchesters-spending-power-8313554 piece on how Tory areas in the South have had their Council budgets increased and Labour voting areas have had their council budgets slashed!


5. DEPORTED while children in care and up for #forcedadoption | A Nigerian Family – Destroyed by Haringey Council – Gagged from Reporting - December 26, 2014

[…] Another sign of the times…Local Government in the UK […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: