jump to navigation

JobBridge… April 26, 2016

Posted by WorldbyStorm in Uncategorized.

Good investigation in the SBP to JobBridge. It’s telling that it is the SBP that has done this, for it isn’t afraid to point to commercial organisations and state organisations which have used it:

…the largest user over its five year lifetime is the HSE which used it 399 times… followed by the GAA (249 internees), Teagasc (184), UCD (184), Hewlett-Packard (176), SuperValu (161) and the ESB (157).

It notes that ‘there is no implication of wrongdoing on behalf of any of these companies. The Department of Social Protection it says is ‘now understood to be advancing plans to name and shame companies found abusing the programme’.

The SBP report is two pages long and lists a range of problems with the scheme – for example in the HSE certain positions filled with JobBridge ‘interns’ do not count as experience for career or qualifications. There are oddities. SuperValu was sixth on the list of high users, but three outlets used the ‘vast majority’ of those employed. Hewlett-Packard, and IBM, both used interns, but as the SBP notes these are companies that have vast profits – in fairness IBM suggests 60-70 per cent of those on the scheme wound up full time employees of the company.

A further point was made by some involved, that by its very existence JobBridge distorts ‘the nature of entry-level employment’ leading to yet another barrier to entry where, as one person on it noted:

Employers expect somebody to come for a job with one or two internships to show that they’re suitable. I think that’s damaging because you’re postponing people’s entry even if they’ve got their qualifications.

The SBP editorial flat out calls for JobBridge to be shut down. It notes that the concept is good but that the actual experience, one where ‘there have been hundreds of complaints to the Department by interns, who are by their very nature vulnerable and underpowered’ is problematic in the extreme. It suggests that the Department ‘has shown little capacity to police and punish those who misses and abuse the scheme’.

And it points to a fundamental issue:

When it comes to private sector companies, there must also be considerable questions about why the state should subsidise their entry level positions, especially when a company is profitable. These positions should be generating payroll and income taxes for the state.


1. dublinstreams - April 26, 2016

were some of these articles not based on an Impact commissioned report some of the key quotes were http://www.impact.ie/impact-calls-for-jobbridge-programme-to-be-dissolved/


WorldbyStorm - April 26, 2016

Its possible, the SBP days documents were released under FOI to it, so also possible it was parallel to Impact. Either way good to see a national newspaper doing dome primary research in the area and unfortunately it may have more influence because it comes from the SBP.


2. Gewerkschaftler - April 26, 2016

Another crack in the facade. Good to see.

But a tactic of the state-for-capitalism since the 80s was always simultaneously to deliver state-subsidised cheap compulsory labour to capital while not undermining the fundamentals of the labour/capital social relations.

Hartz-IV in Germany did and continues to do just this.


3. Tomboktu - April 26, 2016

This year, Ireland is being examined under European human rights law on its conformity to legal obligations on workers’ rights, and the right to freely undertaken work is one of the provisions covered.

I hope Congress submits a shadow report to debunk the government’s claim that all is OK.



Ed - April 26, 2016

BTW, did ICTU formally adopt a position of opposing JobBridge?


CMK - April 26, 2016

The same Congress that used a JobBridge intern to do research?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: