jump to navigation

Positive words for Corbyn and McDonnell’s economic approach October 4, 2016

Posted by WorldbyStorm in Uncategorized.

From William Keegan in the Observer this weekend. He notes that Corbyn’s speech…

It received an execrable reception in the media – as did shadow chancellor John McDonnell’s speech the day before – with cries amounting to “same old story: tax rises, more public spending, masses of borrowing” etc.

Now, I fully understand the wrath of the anti-Corbynistas over the widely reported bullying tactics of Corbyn and McDonnell’s “bovver boys”, and the antipathy towards a “Trotskyite takeover” of the party. When I said to one senior former cabinet minister “it’s just like the early 1980s”, he replied: ‘‘It’s worse than that. At least then we were in control.”

But, Keegan continues:

…there were some good things in the speeches of both Corbyn and McDonnell: they are obviously leading with their chins to boast about “socialism”, even though this word that frightens the media was used in the past by Roy Hattersley, John Smith and even Tony Blair.


…while I can understand the despair of the parliamentary Labour party, I wonder whether the rightwing press that excoriates Corbyn and McDonnell are aware of the wider debate that is going on.

And he notes that the IMF and other international bodies are actually on much the same page as Corbyn and McDonnell. And he makes a very interesting point about the limited nature of the debate in the UK – or rather how that debate is limited on economic matters:

Corbyn and McDonnell call for increased government borrowing, at negligible rates of interest, to boost infrastructure. So do the most orthodox central banking institutions, such as the Bank for International Settlements, based in Basel. The reaction to their calls has been little short of hysterical in some places.

They should not be excoriated for this. More to the point are the widespread concerns that for other reasons, not least their abysmal poll ratings, they are not electable.

He continues with a wish that parliament might veto Brexit. That boat has, I’m afraid, sailed. Some form of Brexit is now inevitable, and it is the shape of that form that is now the battle to be waged.
Be that as it may, reading Keegan for some time now I suspect that he’s a lot more favourable to Corbyn and McDonnell – and their broad approach – and has all along been than a simple reading of this text would suggest. He’s also right.


1. CL - October 5, 2016

“From an economic point of view there is nothing extreme in the argument for large investment programmes, especially after years of fiscal consolidation. Yet the only established political party that offers this choice in Europe is Mr Corbyn’s, which is promising £500bn…

the overwhelming consensus in favour of centrist libertarian economic polities is breaking down.


CL - October 5, 2016
Gewerkschaftler - October 5, 2016

“the overwhelming consensus in favour of centrist libertarian economic polities is breaking down”

Except in Germany, where questioning the value of ‘die Schwarze Null’ (not borrowing to invest – preferably in public infrastructure) is only questioned by mad leftists and malcontents. 😦

Repeat after me: “A country is like a household, but larger…”.


2. Ed - October 5, 2016

I wish he didn’t feel the need to talk about ‘widely reported bullying tactics’ which are as mythical as the ‘widely reported’ menace of immigrants causing every problem in Britain or the ‘widely reported’ menace of welfare fraud, or to speak about ‘antipathy towards a “Trotskyite takeover”‘ without making it clear that nothing of the sort has happened. The Guardian/Observer has been repeating this trash so insistently over the past year that the complete lack of evidence has been buried under a mountain of bullshit.


WorldbyStorm - October 5, 2016

Agreed , what intrigues me is that he says that then gets it out of tgd way and goes on to praise Corbyn et al.I wouldn’t want to work where he is if a ritual criticism is now necessary but that he praises them is telling.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: