jump to navigation

Left Archive: “Militarism vs. Mass Action – Which Road for Irish Struggle?” (reprint from Unfree Citizen, newspaper of People’s Democracy, March 1976). October 18, 2010

Posted by WorldbyStorm in Irish Left Online Document Archive, People's Democracy.

To download the article please click on the following link: Militarism mass action

Many thanks to the person who forwarded this to the Archive.

This is an article, from Intercontinental Press, which reprints a article in the March 1976 edition of Unfree Citizen, newspaper of People’s Democracy (apologies for the quality, but it is a scan of a photocopy). Its significance is that it charts a turn by the admittedly small PD from a quasi militarist rhetorical stance to one of mass action in Northern Ireland. In a way this echoes arguments which had already taken place in Official Sinn Féin and were to take place in Provisional Sinn Féin at a later point (indeed as has been mentioned before the influence of those who arrived from People’s Democracy in PSF in the mid-1980s on that party’s eventual positions is worthy of consideration in its own right).

Of interest is an inset box on the second page which outlines the history of People’s Democracy from radical student activist movement through various splits, ‘a sectarian position to nationalism – it followed a policy designed to drive the ‘Catholic capitalists’ out of the movement’, a turn towards ‘revolutionary nationalism’ and ‘in early 1975 it became clear that it was experimenting with forming its own armed wing’. It concludes ‘Now, with the decline of the Provisional military campaign, PD has evidently decided to make a new reorientation.’

The overall thesis of the article is pessimistic, pointing to a change in a dynamic from a point where ‘we, the Anti-Imperialist movement as a whole had the initiative. We could make or break Prime Ministers and Governments and the hammerblows of mass resistance in 1971-1972 brought down the Stormont regime which had lasted fifty years.

And it notes that ‘it was this spectacle of the whole people in revolt, not just the Provos’ military campaign which brought down Stormont and wrung a whole series of concessions from the British’.

There’s an oddly jarring reference, at least in retrospect, to the death of Frank Stagg, ‘Unfortunately the massive crowd at the funeral doesn’t mean much. The death of a hunger striker is a very emotive issue and the ghoulish behaviour of the Dublin Government made it more emotive still. The emotion doesn’t necessarily carry over into active political support’.

This is contextualised by reference to the changing nature of the armed struggle in the North from the high point of the very early 1970s to a diminishing level with distinctively different characteristics which the article views as ‘elistist and militarist’.

From all of which it determines that ‘The mass movement is all important; physical force, though certainly necessary, is only one of its weapons in the battle and we believe that armed struggle which is not backed by the masses cannot make a revolution’.


1. Starkadder - October 20, 2010

Intercontinental Press? They used to work with the
Revolutionary Marxist Group as well.


2. Bakunin - October 20, 2010

Socialist Workers Party in the US.

Gerry Foley published most his analysis on Ireland in that publication. It had interesting stuff on South Africa, the Palestinians, and the USSR.

It was a great publication — came out every two weeks for most the 1970s up until 1983, I think. It was printed on lousy paper, and you would be covered in black ink when you read it. Sweet.


3. Garibaldy - October 20, 2010

I thought this was a really interesting article. I think the account of the early 1970s probably accurate reflects how a lot of people felt, but wasn’t necessarily the case. As noted above, echoes of debates elsewhere. Be interested to know who wrote it and what position the author/faction whose opinion it represented ended up in.


NollaigO - October 21, 2010

I thought the boxed article summarising the evolution of the People’s Democracy was interesting and accurate. As Bakunin notes, this was probably written by Gerry Foley, an American trotskyist.

IIRC, by the time that article was written, People’s Democracy was a small grouping of under 50 members mainly based in Belfast and London. Their best known member was Michael Farrell. By 1977 they were cooperating closely with the Movement for a Socialist Republic [MSR,formerly the RMG. Both groups merged and kept the name Peoples Democracy. The high point of the new group was during the H block campaign during which they won seats in the 6 County local council elections. After that many left the group and joined Sinn Féin. The few remaining(if the use of the word “few” is not an exaggeration) are members of the Socialist Democracy.
As Bakunin notes, Gerry Foley wrote several articles on Ireland in the Intercontinental Press in the 1970s. He also published a number of interviews with leading republicans. Many of these would be worthy of reprinting including his obituary tributes to Liam McMillan and Malachy McGurren. I read an article, somewhere on the internet, a couple of years ago which stated that Foley was deported from Ireland in the 1980s. I have been unable to find the article since or confirm whether this claim is accurate.


4. Neues aus den Archiven der radikalen (und nicht so radikalen) Linken « Entdinglichung - October 21, 2010

[…] People’s Democracy: Militarism vs. Mass Action – Which Road for Irish Struggle? […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: